Australia is witnessing an extraordinary shift in its political landscape, as a party long confined to the fringes of national politics suddenly finds itself attracting support on a scale that would have seemed improbable only a few years ago. The nationalist-populist One Nation, led – or owned – by Pauline Hanson, has moved from winning around 6% of the vote and the occasional small number of seats in the Senate where proportional representation is used, to now consistently polling around 25%, making the party now a major political force.
Australia has long prided itself on its immunity to the agitated and aggressive political forces that have taken root in other Western countries. But it seems that maybe this was just a case of culture still coming to Australia by ship. Disruptive politics in Australia is now joining similar Western countries, posing a significant threat to Australia’s stability, prosperity and decency.
However, one of the more perplexing features of One Nation’s rise has been the utterly inept way that other political parties have responded to it. The Liberal and National parties (the Coalition) have decided to simply roll over and allow One Nation to cannibalise their vote share. These parties are entirely obsessed with the Labor Party and seem willing to set fire to themselves and the country if they think it might hurt Labor even a little bit.
Labor has chosen to mostly ignore the issue of One Nation’s rise, believing that the party eating into the Coalition’s vote plays to their electoral advantage. However, this approach is deeply irresponsible, as just winning seats in Parliament is not what politics should be about. Major political parties – and as the current federal government – have a responsibility for the health of the broader public realm. There’s a social stewardship that Labor are abdicating in favour of a short-term electoral advantage.
While the Greens simply point their fingers and yell “racist!”. Which is – like everything the Greens do – solely about sending an internal signal within progressive circles. This approach has zero effect on persuading people not to support One Nation.
The narrative used to describe the attraction to One Nation is that people now have a lost sense of control, a feeling among sections of the public that the country is changing in ways they don’t recognise. However, I would argue that, as with other nationalist-populist movements, there is a game of subterfuge being played, as One Nation themselves are the party seeking to change the country. They wrap themselves in the flag as a way of pretending to be patriots, but it’s a trick used to hide their true intent.
Once this is recognised then it offers the other parties a number of arguments to explain to the public just how dangerous One Nation actually are.
Yet to do so, political parties in Australia have to get over their operational belief that the public lacks the adult cognitive abilities to understand complex ideas. There are few countries in the world whose political class talks down to the public the way Australia’s does. Some dipshit political strategists have decided that all Australians only have the mental capacity of a 12 year old and any kind of discussion that goes beyond simplistic slogans and focus-group-tested talking points will simply confuse them.
The following are four ideas that I think can be used to counter One Nation, and to highlight how they are seeking to change Australia for the worse.
One Nation are Trying to Create a Low Trust Society
One Nation’s influence is not simply a political threat, it is a social one. Australia is historically a high-trust society, with a strong tradition of cooperation across ethnic and cultural differences. This social trust is one of the country’s greatest strengths, underpinning its institutions, civic life and economic prosperity. One Nation’s political philosophy challenges this inheritance. It treats cultural and demographic change as undermining social cohesion, promoting a narrow conception of national identity in which belonging is increasingly defined by ethnic and cultural background.
One Nation’s politics seeks to erode the very trust that allows a diverse society to function. By presenting demographic change as a threat, it encourages Australians to view people from different backgrounds with suspicion and as hostile competitors for resources and influence. The party replaces a sense of shared citizenship with an increasingly divisive understanding of society organised around competing group identities – one where you can only trust people who look like you (or vote the way you do).
Political parties need to make this social cost explicit. They should explain that high trust is not an inevitable feature of Australian life, but something built over generations and cannot be taken for granted. Australians should understand that One Nation is not trying to “protect” Australia, they are actually an enormous threat to one of the country’s most valuable assets.
One Nation are Corroding our Bullshit Detector
In 1964 Richard Hofstadter wrote his essay “The Paranoid Style in American Politics” which argued that American political life is often consumed by a style of thinking that interprets all events through elaborate conspiracies which imagines powerful and malevolent enemies – both internal and external – whose hidden machinations are believed to explain almost every political and social development. This has proven fertile ground for cranks, grifters and conmen. The presidency of Donald Trump is the latest expression of this national trait.
Australia has never had such a national trait. As a nation we’ve had a strong bullshit detector, and prided ourselves on our lack of gullibility. Cranks, grifters and conmen have mostly been spotted a mile off and have failed to gain any significant traction in the country’s politics, or our economic and social infrastructure.
However, One Nation are trying to corrode this by importing a paranoid style into Australian politics. One Nation’s senior figures have repeatedly promoted conspiracy theories that portray international institutions and powerful elites as conspiring to control ordinary people. Hanson has linked 15-minute cities and digital identification to fantasies about a one world government. Senator Malcolm Roberts has promoted claims that COVID-19 vaccines are biological weapons, that aircraft are secretly spraying chemtrails and that the World Economic Forum – merely a think tank – is aiming bring societies like Australia under a form of centralised global governance.
Unfortunately, with weakening trust in traditional parties, and with people plugging their brain cells directly into the cynical, bad faith, perpetual bullshit machine that is social media, this corroding of a national trait can be difficult to counteract. There’s a thrill to conspiracy that sober politics can’t provide, and conmen now have a range of new tools at their disposal that makes deception easier to achieve.
However, no-one likes being a sucker, and reminding Australians that reason and rationality have long been a source of national pride should resonate. Australia’s compulsory voting is built on the idea that each citizen has a civic duty, and this civic duty relies upon being responsible adults who live inside reality.
One Nation are Trying to Turn us into a Nation of Whingers
Australians like to think of ourselves as resilient people, capable of weathering adversity without looking for someone else to blame. We value a certain pragmatism, and an ability to distinguish between genuine problems and manufactured grievances. There is a longstanding national pride in getting on with things rather than retreating into self-pity or victimhood.
One Nation are a party of whingers. They have built their political identity around a constant, irrepressible, grievance – presenting almost every aspect of modern Australia as a grave injustice inflicted upon ordinary Australians by governments, the media, and other major institutions. The party encourages people to retreat into resentment, blame and self-pity, rather than resilience. They cultivate a sense that Australians are perpetually being cheated, ignored or victimised.
Hanson presents herself as a permanent victim. Despite being a public figure for three decades, leading a political party that is polling in the mid-20% range, and being actively sponsored by Australia’s richest person, she is mired in a sense of victimhood. She bristles at any kind of questioning of her policies or statements, and refuses to allow media organisations she deems unfriendly into One Nation events. She craves political power, but cannot handle the scrutiny that is essential to it.
Other parties should expose the contradiction between Hanson’s claims of victimhood and the considerable power and influence she now enjoys. They should challenge the idea that every question or criticism is persecution of Hanson, reminding Australians that public life requires scrutiny and accountability. And highlight that resilience – and genuine problem-solving – is a positive virtue within the Australian psyche and we will lose something incredibly important if we allow One Nation to turn us into a nation of whingers.
One Nation are Seeking to Undermine the Rule of Law
One of the most prominent and consequential displays of One Nation’s extremism concerns a former Australian soldier called Ben Roberts-Smith. As part of the elite Special Air Services regiment (SAS), Roberts-Smith won Australia’s highest military honour, the Victoria Cross, for a specific action in Afghanistan. Yet he is also accused of committing war crimes for murdering civilians and unarmed prisoners.
After this was reported in the Australian media, Roberts-Smith attempted to sue The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times over their reporting, claiming the allegations were defamatory. In 2023, the Federal Court found that allegations he was involved in the murder of four Afghan men were substantially true on the balance of probabilities – the standard for a civil trial – and dismissed his case. The Full Federal Court unanimously rejected his appeal in May 2025. The High Court refused to hear the case on further appeal.
In April this year, he was charged with five counts of war crime. One Nation have treated the legal scrutiny of a prominent soldier as an act of national betrayal, suggesting that certain individuals should be protected from the ordinary processes of justice. The party rejects the idea that Australian soldiers should be subject to the rules of engagement, and they place loyalty to a (previously) celebrated figure above the principle that everyone is accountable under the law.
What the party have been trying to do is influence the criminal proceedings against Roberts-Smith. They know that they only have to turn one juror for the case to be dismissed, so are seeking to make as much noise as possible about Roberts-Smith being victimised by “elites” to sow doubt within the jury. There’s also the added element Roberts-Smith represents “real Australian manhood” that is under attack from “feminising” institutions.
One Nation’s actions reflect a rejection of the institutions and conventions that underpin liberal democracy. The party substitutes personal loyalty for the rule of law, and treats independent journalism, judicial scrutiny, and military discipline, as attacks on the nation rather than essential safeguards of it.
The rule of law can sometimes seem abstract, and in an era of heightened group identity, the idea of each individual being treated equally before the law can be deemed inconvenient by people who want their group privileged (or other groups punished). But it’s the bedrock of liberal democracy and One Nation are posing a considerable threat to it. Alongside this, the military’s reputation depends on its willingness to be accountable for its actions. A country that exempts its soldiers from the country’s legal institutions is not defending the country, but weakening it.
Seeing the Party for What it is
One Nation are not a patriotic or even a conservative political party. Like other radical political movements in the West, they are seeking something more fundamental than a change of government or a shift in public policy. They are seeking to transform the character of the country itself.
Plato’s idea of a political regime was not confined to the formal institutions and principles of government. It also encompassed the culture, values, traits and habits of the people living within a society. This is where One Nation’s ambitions become most apparent. They are seeking to cultivate a different kind of citizen: less trusting of others, more suspicious of institutions and expertise, more aggrieved by the world around them and more gullible in accepting conspiracy and misinformation.
The task for Australia’s other political parties is to make this broader threat visible, and to openly challenge the social and civic damage One Nation are seeking to normalise. These parties need to offer a more compelling account of Australian identity, one built around the country’s traditions of social trust, personal resilience, reason and rationality and respect for the rule of law.


